//
you're reading...
Leadership Issues, Teaching and Learning

Creating the conditions for great teachers to thrive

A previous post, What makes a great teacher?, was a popular post. I suppose that’s not surprising; people are intrigued to know what the answer might be. Am I a great teacher? Can I be a great teacher? What would it take for me to feel that this applies to me? We all want to know. I’m the same. But as a Headteacher, I have to ask myself another set of questions:

  • Where teachers are already ‘great teachers’, am I doing enough to reward and motivate them? Are we helping them to be great teachers or are we putting obstacles in the way?
  • Where teachers are on the way or have the potential to be really great teachers am I doing enough to encourage them, to guide them, to motivate them?
  • I also have to ask if there are teachers who would need significant support and guidance to approach the level ‘great’ suggests. Am I doing enough for them too?

I’m not going to use this post to describe the full gamut of accountability systems we deploy or the CPD opportunities that we offer. Here, I’m interested in the spirit of a school; the ethos and culture that need to pervade a school so that ‘great teachers’ thrive and all teachers continually strive to emulate them. What are the prevailing conditions needed to enable a rich array of teacher-talent to develop and flourish!? (And in doing this, I’m not saying that I’ve cracked it in my school; but I am working on it!)

I think it comes down to a few key principles and this is an attempt to capture the essence:

Purpose: All organisations are essentially collections of individuals with their own personal values and goals. The role of leaders is to try to create the maximum alignment for those values and goals so that everyone pulls in the same direction to the greatest extent. Really strong teachers tend to have strong views about education, about teaching and learning and about relationships with students; they have an intrinsic sense of purpose. However, it doesn’t work for them or the school if they are fighting against the flow; you want them with you, not against you. This requires either a clear, inspiring vision that they buy into, or, more probably, it requires a process that involves them in shaping the vision in the first place. It’s demotivating in the extreme to be asked to work towards goals you don’t believe in; in fact it doesn’t work at all. So, the question is: am I doing enough to forge a sense of common purpose amongst the key drivers in my school? Are we as closely aligned in our goals as we can be? (See the force-field analogy)

Challenge: Talented people thrive in a high-demand environment. Great teachers who drive students towards ever higher standards, expect standards to be high all around them. They are usually demanding of themselves and of others; rightly so. This means you have to expect the challenge to be a two-way process; you push me; I’ll push you and we’ll do a better job. That means we need mechanisms that actively seek out opinions and ideas that would lead to improvement. It is also means that we should do all we can to sustain a culture where rigour, high quality and doing things properly pervades. It is acceptable to be very demanding of people if they too can be demanding of you. (Does the converse need spelling out?)

Autonomy: Fundamentally, if we think we’re doing a decent job (and if we’re not), we like to be left alone. Autonomy is the thing teachers crave. I know what I’m doing, let me get on with it. Don’t tell me what to do because I’ve already got enough ideas of my own… It is the great joy of teaching; the freedom to experiment, to perform, to follow your whims, to be yourself…. and those great teachers are no different. Any process that restricts, inhibits, limits, deflects, blocks, restrains… for no reason other than a perceived need for conformity and uniformity or purely to satisfy an accountability measure…. is likely to frustrate great teachers. Conversely, if they feel at liberty to make choices, to do their own thing, to go way off piste whenever they want to….they’ll be flourishing. Real autonomy isn’t automatic; it emerges from a culture where there is a high level of confidence, professional respect and mutual trust. Question: where are we along the control-autonomy axis? How much more freedom could I give teachers within the context of my school?

Growth: Great teachers are learners; they want to move forward. Usually, they have mastered the key skills in teaching and are looking to refine their practice or explore innovations of various forms. They want the space and time to grow professionally. However, this has to be seen in the context where all teachers are working collaboratively, forming larger groups where the levels of expertise will vary. This is the challenge; can I provide the range of growth opportunities needed to move the very best forward, without them getting unduly bogged down in ‘whole staff INSET’ that they don’t really need. Is this a case of harnessing their talent to help support the development of others or of providing CPD opportunities more orientated towards individual research and innovation? How far have I gone in tailoring CPD for each individual? Or is there still a bit of ‘egg sucking’ that still needs to be eliminated?

Recognition: This is a key motivating factor but we are not talking simply about financial reward. Maximising pay is important but salary increments never do justice to the additional value really great teachers deliver. It is also often the case that very strong teachers are self-effacing, don’t want a fuss made and don’t court public affirmation. What matters is often simply that their work is recognised, acknowledged, appreciated, and not taken for granted. Beyond the rigmarole of formal lesson observations and examination postmortems, there needs to be a culture where excellence is acknowledged on an individual basis and celebrated publicly. This isn’t to create divisions – it is to identify where we have role models, to have exemplars for others to follow and, crucially, to ensure that the exponents of great teaching get the recognition they deserve. If you have a lot of teachers like this, then you need to apply this to them all. Do I do enough in this area? No… but I must and will do more!

Care: Finally, it is important to create a culture where teachers are looked after as people. Great teachers often have a touch of the ’tis but a scratch’ attitude. But, as in the Geese analogy, everyone needs to fall to the back of the pack from time to time or, if necessary, be nursed back to health before rejoining the flock. High performing people are not immune to stress or the usual array of health or personal set-backs. I’m a great believer that you get more from everyone by being conspicuously supportive with personal issues. Whether this is taking a flexible approach to part-time working, returning from maternity leave, enabling people to see children in their primary assembly or graduation, helping people to look after elderly parents or simply get to the bank.. it pays to be generous and flexible. I always say ‘family first’ because that is how I feel about my own. If you want people to give their all, they need to feel that the trade-off is worthwhile; the community spirit fostered by a strong family-first approach, nurtures loyalty, commitment and the determination to strive for success. Everyone benefits. I think we do pretty well here… but there is always more!

So, there we are: the conditions for great teachers to thrive: Purpose, Challenge, Automony, Growth, Recognition, Care.

Related Posts:

http://headguruteacher.com/category/teaching-and-learning/great-lessons/

How do I know how good my teachers are?

Research as CPD: CPD as Research

 

Discussion

28 thoughts on “Creating the conditions for great teachers to thrive

  1. As an aspiring great teacher, this article helps me to appreciate how dependent I am for my success on those more senior to me. My HOD is particularly adept at clearing obstacles from our path in the department. I now realise this has been a key contributing factor to our development in recent times.

    I’m going to go to school and thank her.

    Posted by Christopher Waugh | September 23, 2012, 7:39 am
  2. Fantastic post

    Posted by David Dunn | September 23, 2012, 10:25 am
  3. I really like this post and can definitely identify how some of these conditions are vital to me as a practitioner, particularly how crucial autonomy is for a rewarding job, and you don’t realise how much you need it until you no longer have it!

    I think that if you can sustain a healthy combination of these factors within the staff at your school; the only result can be progress and improvement (for students and staff!).

    Posted by Zoe Andrews (@ZoeAndrewsAST) | September 23, 2012, 9:10 pm
  4. Why oh why are these fairly basic prerequisites to developing an maintaining high quality teachers so commonly misunderstood or ignored by so many leadership teams around the country? It is an educational mystery that is begging to be solved…

    Posted by Seeking Sir | January 4, 2013, 8:40 pm
  5. Why oh why are these fairly basic prerequisites to developing and maintaining high quality teachers so commonly misunderstood or ignored by so many leadership teams around the country? It is an educational mystery that is begging to be solved… I live in hope that certain head-teachers will stumble across this and amend their tragicomic ‘leadership’ accordingly.

    Posted by Seeking Sir | January 4, 2013, 8:42 pm
  6. What school do you supervise, and can you PLEASE clone yourself? There are so many of us that are devalued, treated as drones, and shackled by “fidelity to curriculum.”

    Posted by Michelle | March 17, 2013, 9:29 pm
  7. Hi headguruteacher, I’m interested in you speaking at a conference I am running in March 2014 on creating great teachers. Could you contact me at sonia@ukheadsup.com to discuss this?

    With thanks

    Sonia

    Posted by Sonia Gill | April 19, 2013, 3:02 pm
  8. Another brilliant post outlining the obvious. Value your staff and acknowledge their efforts, encourage autonomy and freedom to take risks. Support and challenge is intrinsically linked with everyone working towards a shared vision. These factors combined enable staff to be great teachers!

    Posted by Yvonne Nunn | June 25, 2013, 6:24 am
  9. As always your comments and thoughts are spot on. Inspirational.

    Posted by J Davis | August 26, 2013, 7:05 pm
  10. Hello

    I have followed you on Twitter [as AnnLitchfield] and read your blog with interest for some time. This is incredibly cheeky – but could I please ask your advice on a work issue?

    Posted by Fela Heen | September 14, 2013, 6:43 pm
  11. I’ve been a teacher for over 30 years and this is the best article on education I have ever read. I wish this was required reading and mantra for every member of every SMT in every school in the UK! I have just taken early retirement from my school because I felt so demoralised, de-skilled and undervalued by the SMT, despite being passionate about my work, having great relationships with my pupils, being innovative and creative, getting excellent results, passing all inspections with aplomb and having a first class reputation among parents. Your article has helped me to see exactly why I felt so drained by the system I was in, which was the polar opposite to the one you aspire to. Thank you SO much for helping me feel that this wasn’t, as I was lead to believe, all my own fault.

    On a more positive note, I am now working as a private tutor and absolutely love teaching one to one. My boss (me) is a demon with very high expectations and demands of me but she allows me to teach in innovative and creative ways and will try to ensure she remembers all of the points you’ve made. Many, many thanks for your clear and insightful writing.

    Posted by Helen | October 13, 2013, 5:23 pm
  12. Fantastic post. Rewarding and encouraging great teachers is key. If a teacher is not enjoying their job, that will reflect poorly on their work and will cause the students to suffer. And that simply just wouldn’t do!

    Thanks for sharing your thoughts!
    Victoria

    Posted by Victoria Ross | July 3, 2014, 8:07 pm

Trackbacks/Pingbacks

  1. Pingback: “The Edutronic”: A great teacher flourishing « headguruteacher - October 6, 2012

  2. Pingback: How do I know how good my teachers are? « headguruteacher - December 4, 2012

  3. Pingback: What makes a great teacher? | headguruteacher - March 10, 2013

  4. Pingback: My Blog Manifesto | headguruteacher - July 9, 2013

  5. Pingback: My blog manifesto - July 11, 2013

  6. Pingback: Top Twelve: Highly Effective School Leadership | From the Sandpit.... - July 25, 2013

  7. Pingback: School Leadership: Blog collection | headguruteacher - August 26, 2013

  8. Pingback: Great School Leadership 1: Ethos | headguruteacher - September 9, 2013

  9. Pingback: Great School Leadership 4: People | headguruteacher - September 24, 2013

  10. Pingback: Northern Rocks Presentation: Cultivating a ‘research-engaged learning community’ | headguruteacher - June 8, 2014

  11. Pingback: Creating the conditions for great teachers to t... - June 8, 2014

  12. Pingback: Reclaiming Pedagogy | Belmont Teach - August 29, 2014

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Archives

Blog Stats

  • 953,929 hits

Twitter Updates

Follow

Get every new post delivered to your Inbox.

Join 23,269 other followers

%d bloggers like this: